By Rob Delaney | 25 September 2007
Sept. 25 (Bloomberg)—
- On Baffin Island in the Arctic Circle, Baffinland Iron Mines Corp. almost missed its window to ship provisions to workers before winter arrives. The delay came not from the weather, but from a sudden freeze in the market for short-term debt 2,000 miles south in Toronto.
"We have 200 people to keep alive," Chief Executive Officer Gordon McCreary said in an interview in Toronto. "Our lifeline to getting critical materials to the north" was the C$43.8 million ($43.8 million) invested in commercial paper, he said.
The Canadian cash crunch that started with defaults on subprime mortgages in Southern California and Florida has hurt more than 25 companies that invested in commercial paper, including Sun-Times Media Group Inc. and Canada Post, the nation's mail service. Baffinland has 95 percent of its cash in Canadian commercial paper, debt that is due in 364 days or less.
Investors fled Canada's asset-backed commercial paper, paralyzing the C$40 billion market for debt that carried the highest credit ratings, after losses from home loans to people with poor credit histories roiled global credit markets.
Coventree Can't Pay
That left Baffinland and other investors in the lurch because 17 funds run by finance companies including Toronto— based Coventree Inc., Newshore Financial Corp. and Quanto Financial Corp., couldn't raise money to pay back lenders, according to ratings company DBRS Ltd.
Coventree managed C$16 billion in commercial paper funds with the highest ratings.
The funds run by companies such as Coventree paid interest of about 4.6 percent for 30 days, compared with three-month Canadian government bills that yielded 4.35 percent. The debt is backed by mortgages, corporate bonds, and car loans that typically yield as much as 1 percentage point more than commercial paper, according to Colin Kilgour, president of Connor Clark & Lunn Wholesale Finance, the structured credit and securitization unit of Connor Clark & Lunn Financial Group.
About 4 percent of Coventree's commercial paper was backed by subprime mortgages.
No commercial paper borrower had failed to pay on time in two decades and Toronto-based DBRS gave the securities its top rating of R-1. The funds also had backup lines of credit from banks should a market disruption shut down the market.
Canada's asset-backed commercial paper market doubled to C$120 billion since 2000, according to Moody's Investors Service in New York. Buyers snapped up the IOUs as government debt sales fell 60 percent to C$23.5 billion in the past decade after nine straight surpluses, according to the March budget.
`Concept of Risk'
"You can get what the bank pays you, which is not very much, or you can put it in asset-backed commercial paper, which have always been rated as high as you can get so there's never been any concept of risk," said Geoff Chater, a spokesman for Vancouver-based First Quantum Resources Minerals Ltd., a copper mining company operating in Africa.
First Quantum hasn't been repaid on C$7.5 million of debt issued by Coventree that matured on Aug. 14 and Aug. 15, he said. It had about 28 percent of its cash in commercial paper.
Six-Year Highs
Starting in July, growing defaults in U.S. home loans caused the cost of borrowing to increase for all but the most creditworthy companies. Rates on asset-backed commercial paper soared, rising to six-year highs in the U.S. as the three-month London interbank offered rate, or Libor, climbed to 5.82 percent from 5.35 percent. Libor is a benchmark for commercial paper rates.
Making matters worse banks, including Frankfurt-based Deutsche Bank AG and Barclays Bank Plc of London, refused to provide emergency financing. They said there was no market disruption because some of Canada's biggest commercial banks were able to refinance debt.
Investors began demanding yields of about 6.03 percent to own Coventree's commercial paper. On Aug. 13 the company said it couldn't find enough buyers to refinance C$950 million of short=term debt and its banks refused to provide emergency funds. Company spokesman Craig Armitage declined to comment.
"Anytime there's a reliance on short-term funding without specific alternative plans for liquidity, that's going to be suspect," said John Hollyer, principal at Valley Forge, Pennsylvania-based Vanguard Group Inc., which has $170 billion in money market funds under management. "That's the overriding lesson of what happened here."
Debt Extension
A group of 10 banks and pension funds agreed on Aug. 16 to convert C$35 billion of debt into notes maturing in as much as 10 years. Terms of the debt won't be released until mid-October, said Purdy Crawford, a lawyer at the Toronto firm Osler, Hoskin & Harcourt LLP who heads the group. Until then, investors won't know when they will get their money back, or whether they will be repaid in full.
Deutsche Bank spokesman Ted Meyer in New York declined to comment, as did Barclays spokesman Peter Truell, also in New York.
Companies invested in the debt in part because of the ratings from DBRS, formerly Dominion Bond Rating Service, said Robin Roopchan, director of investor relations at Ontario Power Generation in Toronto, which bought C$103 million of the securities, none of which has been repaid.
`Global Liquidity'
DBRS figured on banks providing funds, said Managing Director Huston Loke.
"We expected a combination of the market and liquidity providers would have carried investors through," Loke said in an interview. The disruption clause "took good care of the market for 18 years," he said.
DBRS said Sept. 12 it will change its rating rules and adopt a "global liquidity" standard to prevent debt getting the highest credit rating if banks can refuse to provide funding.
"The banks are saying there's no market disruption, and obviously there is a market disruption," said Troy Winsor, a spokesman for Redcorp Ventures Ltd., based in Vancouver.
Redcorp put 43 percent of its money in Coventree commercial paper on the advice of HSBC Canada, Winsor said. Redcorp is building a copper, zinc and lead mine in British Columbia.
Sharon Wilks, a spokeswoman in Toronto for HSBC Canada, a unit of HSBC Holdings Plc, Europe's biggest bank, declined to comment. HSBC is among the banks working on the debt plan.
`Driving On'
Canada Post had about 3.5 percent, or C$37.9 million, of its treasury investments in asset-backed commercial paper, according to John Caines, manager for media relations. The company is representing investors negotiating with the banks.
Sun-Times, the publisher of the Chicago Sun-Times newspaper formerly controlled by convicted felon Conrad Black, said it doesn't anticipate a "major capital loss" after two trusts failed to pay back C$48 million in commercial paper.
The company signed "standstill" agreements in August with both National Bank of Canada's Ironstone Trust and Coventree's Planet Trust to avoid taking legal action until Oct. 15, Sun— Times spokesman Tammy Chase said.
Baffinland bought commercial paper on the advice of Toronto-based Bank of Nova Scotia. McCreary wouldn't say how much interest he is now paying on the C$21 million credit line.
"We're driving on," McCreary said.
Normxxx
______________
The contents of any third-party letters/reports above do not necessarily reflect the opinions or viewpoint of normxxx. They are provided for informational/educational purposes only.
The content of any message or post by normxxx anywhere on this site is not to be construed as constituting market or investment advice. Such is intended for educational purposes only. Individuals should always consult with their own advisors for specific investment advice.
No comments:
Post a Comment